Indiana Health Insurance Broker & Agent: Compare Off-Exchange Plans
November 14, 2026 · by Bernie Sobalvarro
285+ reviews on Google and Facebook

Led by Bernie Sobalvarro, Senior Advisor, with his team of licensed agents
Eric VasquezLicensed agent
Ayoub CherifLicensed agent
Kevin LimaLicensed agent
Mark YacoobLicensed agent
Kevin McCarthyLicensed agent
Arianna SoasLicensed agent
If you are looking for a health insurance broker or agent in Indiana who will compare plans with you, I am Bernie Sobalvarro, an independent health insurance advisor and licensed broker (NPN 19189235), licensed in Indiana and 30 other states. For people, I put full-price ACA plans side by side with private, medically underwritten and off-exchange options, by phone or webinar screen share. I work for you, not for one insurance company.
Most Hoosiers who call me have already looked at the marketplace, earn too much for a subsidy, and found the full-price plans too expensive. If you are healthy, you may qualify for private, medically underwritten or off-exchange coverage. I compare private health insurance in Indiana side by side with the full-price plan, for self-employed people, 1099 contractors, families and small business owners. You can check my Indiana license on the NIPR license lookup or on our state licenses page.
Who our licensed agents help in Indiana
These are the six situations our brokers see most from Indiana. We do not sell Medicare or Medicaid plans. If you are in good health, private underwritten coverage is usually worth pricing beside a full-price plan.
- Turning 26
Turning 26
Coming off a parent’s plan at 26? Young adults can usually stay on a parent’s plan until they turn 26 (HealthCare.gov). After that, healthy applicants can compare private underwritten plans with full-price ACA plans.
- High earners
Over the subsidy limit
Professionals and households in Indianapolis and Fort Wayne above the subsidy cutoff pay the whole premium. We compare that number with private underwritten options, which ask health questions and can decline.
- Self-employed & 1099
Working for yourself
Working for yourself in Fort Wayne or anywhere in Indiana? We check networks for the doctors you use, deductibles and premiums across private and full-price plans.
- Leaving a job / COBRA
COBRA too expensive
If your job-based coverage is ending, timing matters. We look at COBRA, private underwritten plans and full-price plans, and at when each one could start.
- Families
Families comparing employer coverage
Families in Fort Wayne and across Indiana often find the employer family rate higher than expected. We compare it with individual private and full-price plans, by phone or webinar screen share.
- Small business 2–30
Coverage for a small staff
Offering coverage to a staff of 2 to 30 is a big call for a small business. We price the group options and the owner’s own private coverage side by side.
Not sure which one fits? A licensed agent can usually sort it out in a few minutes on the phone.
Self-employed health insurance in Indiana: who I help
If you searched for a health insurance broker in Indianapolis or Fort Wayne, here is who I work with: consultants and business owners in Indianapolis, Carmel, Fishers and Zionsville, tradespeople and manufacturing contractors in Fort Wayne and Elkhart, and self-employed families in Evansville, South Bend and Bloomington. I help anywhere in Indiana by phone or webinar screen share.
Indiana has 591,671 small businesses, and 480,921 of them have no paid employees. Small businesses employ about 1.2 million people, 43.2 percent of Indiana employees (SBA Office of Advocacy, 2025 profile). Ask your tax professional whether self-employed premiums are deductible in your situation. This is general information, not tax advice.
Indiana residents shop for ACA coverage on HealthCare.gov (KFF, 2027 marketplace types), and a full-price quote from there gives us a useful reference. I compare that number with private and off-exchange choices. My Indiana license is issued by the Indiana Department of Insurance, which oversees insurance agents in the state.
Off-exchange and private health insurance in Indiana
Off-exchange coverage is bought directly from an insurer or through a broker rather than through the state exchange. It can be an ACA-compliant plan or a type of coverage that follows different rules, and federal premium help is not available outside the exchange (KFF). For Indiana households that would not get meaningful premium help anyway, that last point matters less.
A medically underwritten plan asks health questions on the application. The insurer uses your answers to decide whether to approve you and on what terms, so approval is not guaranteed, and these plans may limit coverage for pre-existing conditions and do not carry all of the ACA’s protections (Georgetown CHIR). For a healthy Indiana applicant, that is the trade-off worth pricing. Some private plans use PPO-style networks; availability depends on your county and the plan.
Full-price plan too expensive? How an Indiana health insurance broker compares your options
For Indiana households above the subsidy range, the comparison is a full-price ACA plan against off-exchange and private options. We check whether your doctors and hospitals in central Indiana or your region are in network, the deductible and out-of-pocket limit, what is covered and excluded, how pre-existing conditions are handled, renewal terms and price. No blanket “any doctor” promises; we confirm providers for each plan.
An ACA plan cannot turn you down or charge you more because of your health; an underwritten plan can. If something in your health history could affect approval, a full-price ACA plan may be the better fit, and I will say so plainly.
Applying outside open enrollment
The two kinds of coverage run on different calendars. ACA individual-market plans, on or off the exchange, are sold during open enrollment or after a qualifying event opens a special enrollment period (45 CFR 147.104). Underwritten plans outside the ACA individual market generally accept applications year-round. We confirm the effective date and local availability before you apply.
Small business health insurance in Indiana
Own an Indiana business with a few employees? We can compare a small group plan with individual private coverage for you and your staff. The small business page explains how that review works.
Talk with an Indiana health insurance agent
Have your zip code and the birthdates for everyone on the plan. From there it is a 15-minute conversation by phone or webinar screen share and a written side-by-side I send right after. There is no obligation, and we can do it all in Spanish if you prefer. Family in another state? I am licensed in 31 states, including Florida and Texas; there is also our Florida guide and Houston page. The full list is on our state licenses page.
Frequently asked questions
Are you a licensed health insurance agent in Indiana?
Yes. I am a licensed health insurance agent and broker in Indiana (NPN 19189235). I am based in Florida and work with Indiana clients by phone or webinar screen share, from Fort Wayne to Evansville. You can verify my license on the NIPR lookup.
I priced a full-price plan and it was too expensive. What are my private options in Indiana?
If your health is good, a private underwritten plan may be an option. It asks health questions, approval is not guaranteed and pre-existing conditions can be limited (Georgetown CHIR). We put it next to the full-price plan you priced so the trade-offs are clear.
What is off-exchange health insurance in Indiana?
“Off-exchange” only describes where the plan is bought: directly from a carrier or through a broker. The plan may follow ACA rules or different ones. Premium tax credits are not available off the exchange, per KFF.
Can I get private health insurance in Indiana outside open enrollment?
Often, yes. Underwritten plans that are not ACA individual-market coverage generally take applications through the year, while ACA plans on or off the exchange keep to open and special enrollment. We confirm before you apply.
What self-employed health insurance options are available in Indiana?
No plan fits everyone. Healthy self-employed Hoosiers who earn too much for subsidies often compare an off-exchange or private underwritten plan with a full-price ACA plan; if a condition could affect approval, the ACA plan may be the safer choice. I show you both.
Is a health insurance broker more expensive than buying direct?
No. I am paid by the insurance company, not by a fee from you, and your premium is the same either way.
I’m 25 and on a parent’s plan in Indiana. What should I do before 26?
Turning 26 generally ends dependent coverage; check the exact end date with the parent’s plan (HealthCare.gov). Loss of that coverage is usually a qualifying life event for ACA plans (HealthCare.gov). Healthy young adults in Indiana can also price private underwritten coverage, and we lay out the trade-offs side by side.
Should I take COBRA or look at other plans in Indiana?
COBRA is not the only choice. It continues your group plan, often at the full premium plus up to a 2% fee (U.S. Department of Labor). Private, medically underwritten plans ask health questions and may decline, while full-price ACA plans do not; we compare all of them with your COBRA quote.
Do you sell Medicare plans in Indiana?
No. We do not sell Medicare or Medicaid plans.
Want to talk with a licensed advisor about private or full-price plans? Get a Quote. Hablamos Español. More general questions are on the FAQ page.
Sobal Nationwide Health does not sell Medicare or Medicaid plans.
