Wisconsin Health Insurance Broker & Agent: Compare Private Plans
November 14, 2026 · by Bernie Sobalvarro
285+ reviews on Google and Facebook

Led by Bernie Sobalvarro, Senior Advisor, with his team of licensed agents
Eric VasquezLicensed agent
Ayoub CherifLicensed agent
Kevin LimaLicensed agent
Mark YacoobLicensed agent
Kevin McCarthyLicensed agent
Arianna SoasLicensed agent
Need a Wisconsin health insurance broker or agent who looks at more than one carrier? I am Bernie Sobalvarro, an independent health insurance advisor and licensed broker (NPN 19189235), licensed in Wisconsin and 30 other states. By phone or webinar screen share, I compare full-price ACA plans with private, medically underwritten coverage for people in Milwaukee, Madison, Green Bay, Appleton and Eau Claire. I work for you, not an insurance company.
Wisconsinites usually come to me after pricing a plan, learning they earn too much for a subsidy, and seeing a full price they did not expect. If you are healthy, you may qualify for private, medically underwritten coverage, and I compare it with the full-price plan you already saw. I mostly help self-employed people, farm families, 1099 contractors and small business owners. You can check my Wisconsin license on the NIPR license lookup or on our state licenses page.
Who our licensed brokers help in Wisconsin
Most Wisconsin clients who call our licensed brokers are in one of six situations. We do not sell Medicare or Medicaid plans, and most of these clients are healthy enough to look at private, medically underwritten plans next to full-price ACA coverage.
- Turning 26
Off Mom or Dad’s plan
Aging off a parent’s plan? Whether you start a job without benefits or work for yourself, we compare private underwritten coverage with full-price plans by phone or webinar screen share.
- High earners
Over the subsidy limit
Professionals and households in Milwaukee and Madison above the subsidy cutoff pay the whole premium. We compare that number with private underwritten options, which ask health questions and can decline.
- Self-employed & 1099
Self-employed, 1099 and freelance
Consultants, contractors and freelancers in Milwaukee with no employer plan. We compare individual private and full-price plans; the premium deduction question goes to your tax professional.
- Leaving a job / COBRA
Leaving COBRA or a job plan
Left a job or got a COBRA notice? COBRA keeps your old plan, but you may pay the full premium plus a fee (U.S. Department of Labor). We compare it with private underwritten and full-price plans before your deadline.
- Families
Covering a spouse and children
If your employer pays for you but not much toward dependents, the family premium can sting. We check private underwritten plans for healthy family members and the full-price ACA alternative.
- Small business 2–30
Coverage for a small staff
Offering coverage to a staff of 2 to 30 is a big call for a small business. We price the group options and the owner’s own private coverage side by side.
Situations overlap: a business owner leaving COBRA, a family with a 26-year-old. We build one comparison around all of it.
Self-employed health insurance in Wisconsin: who I help
If you searched for a health insurance broker in Milwaukee or Madison, here is who I work with: manufacturing and trade business owners in Milwaukee and Waukesha, consultants, researchers and tech contractors in Madison, owners and families in Green Bay, Appleton and Oshkosh, and dairy and farm families plus self-employed people around Eau Claire and La Crosse. I help anywhere in Wisconsin by phone or webinar screen share.
Of the 497,370 small businesses in Wisconsin, 389,776 have no employees at all, and small firms account for 48.0 percent of Wisconsin employees, about 1.2 million people (SBA Office of Advocacy, 2025 profile). Whether your premiums are deductible when you work for yourself is a question for your tax professional; this is general information, not tax advice.
Wisconsin uses HealthCare.gov as its marketplace for 2027 coverage (KFF, 2027 marketplace types). If that is where you priced a plan, we can use it as your starting point. ACA plans are also sold off-exchange at full price, and private underwritten options sit outside the marketplace entirely. Insurers and agents in Wisconsin are regulated by the Wisconsin Office of the Commissioner of Insurance.
Private health insurance in Wisconsin: underwritten and off-exchange plans
Think of the exchange as one storefront among several. ACA-compliant plans, and coverage that follows different rules, can also be bought from an insurer directly or through a licensed broker. Federal premium help does not follow you off the exchange (KFF), which matters little if your income already rules it out.
A medically underwritten plan asks health questions on the application. The insurer uses your answers to decide whether to approve you and on what terms, so approval is not guaranteed, and these plans may limit coverage for pre-existing conditions and do not carry all of the ACA’s protections (Georgetown CHIR). Many Wisconsinites ask about private health insurance; some private plans do use PPO-style networks, but what is available depends on your county and the plan, so we check first. For healthy applicants, that trade-off is worth pricing.
Full-price plan too expensive? How a Wisconsin health insurance broker compares your options
A Wisconsin comparison covers the full-price ACA plan and each private option: whether your doctors and health systems in Milwaukee, Madison or the Fox Valley are in network, PPO-style versus narrower networks, the deductible and out-of-pocket limit, covered services and exclusions, pre-existing condition terms, renewal and the monthly price. I will not say “any doctor” is covered; we check them.
ACA plans accept everyone regardless of health; underwritten plans do not have to. If approval looks unlikely, or a condition would be excluded, the full-price ACA plan is often the better answer, and I will tell you that up front.
Applying outside open enrollment
The two kinds of coverage run on different calendars. ACA individual-market plans, on or off the exchange, are sold during open enrollment or after a qualifying event opens a special enrollment period (45 CFR 147.104). Underwritten plans outside the ACA individual market generally accept applications year-round. We confirm the effective date and local availability before you apply.
Small business health insurance in Wisconsin
Own a Wisconsin business with a few employees? We can compare a small group plan with individual private coverage for you and your team before you choose. See the small business page.
Talk with a Wisconsin health insurance agent
Have your zip code and the birthdates for everyone on the plan. From there it is a 15-minute conversation by phone or webinar screen share and a written side-by-side I send right after. There is no obligation, and we can do it all in Spanish if you prefer. Family in another state? I am licensed in 31 states, including Florida and Texas; there is also our Florida guide and Houston page. The full list is on our state licenses page.
Frequently asked questions
Are you a licensed health insurance agent in Wisconsin?
Yes. I am licensed in Wisconsin as a health insurance agent and broker, NPN 19189235. I am based in Florida and help Wisconsin clients by phone or webinar screen share, from Milwaukee to Eau Claire. You can confirm my license on the NIPR lookup.
I priced a full-price plan and it was too expensive. What are my private options in Wisconsin?
If you are healthy, you may qualify for a private, medically underwritten plan. The insurer asks health questions and decides approval, terms and price, so nothing is guaranteed and pre-existing conditions may be limited or excluded, per Georgetown CHIR. I compare those options side by side with the full-price plan you already saw.
What is an off-exchange health insurance plan?
A policy purchased without going through the exchange. Some off-exchange plans meet ACA rules and some are other kinds of coverage; either way, federal premium help is limited to exchange plans (KFF).
Can I get private health insurance in Wisconsin outside open enrollment?
For medically underwritten plans that are not ACA individual-market coverage, usually yes. ACA plans, on or off the exchange, follow open and special enrollment periods. We confirm the rules for the specific plan before you apply.
What self-employed health insurance options are available in Wisconsin?
There is no single best plan. A healthy self-employed person in Wisconsin who earns too much for subsidies may want to compare a private underwritten plan; if your health could affect approval, a full-price ACA plan may be the better fit. I put them side by side.
Do I pay a fee to use a health insurance agent?
No. I am paid by the insurance company, not by a fee from you, and your premium is the same either way.
I’m aging off my parent’s plan at 26 in Wisconsin. What can I do?
Ask the parent’s plan when your dependent coverage ends, since it is usually at 26 but dates differ (HealthCare.gov). Then compare: a full-price ACA plan with no health questions, or a private, medically underwritten plan that may cost less if you are healthy but can limit pre-existing conditions.
My job coverage is ending. Is COBRA my only option in Wisconsin?
COBRA is not the only choice. It continues your group plan, often at the full premium plus up to a 2% fee (U.S. Department of Labor). Private, medically underwritten plans ask health questions and may decline, while full-price ACA plans do not; we compare all of them with your COBRA quote.
Do you sell Medicare plans in Wisconsin?
No. We do not sell Medicare or Medicaid plans.
Want to talk with a licensed advisor about private or full-price plans? Get a Quote. Hablamos Español. More general questions are on the FAQ page.
Sobal Nationwide Health does not sell Medicare or Medicaid plans.
